Skip to main content

Ravens can't keep giving LaJohntay Wester chances after first half disaster

ByConnor Burke
Baltimore Ravens wide receiver LaJohntay Wester
Baltimore Ravens wide receiver LaJohntay Wester | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

The Baltimore Ravens need to end the LaJohntay Wester experiment. He hasn’t been the punt returner this team needs, and in the first half of Week 11, he had the worst outing of his career. He muffed two punts, one of which was recovered by the Carolina Panthers and led to a touchdown.

Keyon Martin recovered the other muff at Baltimore’s one-yard line, and if we’re being honest, the Panthers had every chance to recover it.

2026 hasn’t been kind to Wester. He’s been underwhelming and extremely passive in his chances. He came out of Colorado as an explosive player in space, and in Year 2, we still haven’t seen that consistently show up in the regular season. The 24-year-old can get loose for the occasional 10- to 20+-yard return, but that’s it.

It’s time to take away punt return duties, and maybe even cut him. It’s just not working out.

Baltimore Ravens may need to move on from LaJohntay Wester amid poor season

LaJohntay Wester’s recent struggles have been brutal. He fumbled a kick return against the Jacksonville Jaguars that eventually led to six points the other way. In Week 11, neither punt return seemed difficult to field; he just dropped the first one and let the second hit his facemask.

Wester has nowhere to hide either. If he were a dangerous weapon like a Devin Hester or DeSean Jackson, we wouldn’t be talking about this. But he’s far from that. In fact, he’s been more of a liability, if anything.

There have been too many occasions where Wester calls for a fair catch with plenty of room in front of him. Other times, his feet are planted around his own five-yard line. Make the opposing punt coverage work for punts inside the 10; don’t just hand it to them.

The speed and big-play ability that Wester showed in the 2025 preseason isn’t showing up either. He returned the second punt he saw in his NFL career for a touchdown in last year’s preseason opener. Since then, he’s lacked that electricity.

On 13 returns, Wester has mustered a subpar 123 return yards on punts. That’s 9.5 yards per return. In the game of field position, the Ravens have come up on the short end of the stick more often than not with Wester back there.

Is there a world where Wester is cut after this week? I wouldn’t put it past the Ravens, but at this point in the year, it’s probably pointless. They’re not really in playoff contention, so they’re not desperate to make moves, and you can simply make Wester a healthy scratch from here on out.

At the very least, he can’t return any more punts. That goes for the rest of Week 11 and beyond. Baltimore needs to fire him from that job. It should be a gig for Tez Walker or even Elijah Sarratt to take now.

Add us as a preferred source on Google